{"release":{"id":"2d86bd12ba77a288053b34ea2517324b92d03c8039b7f5d156fa4002421384a1","published":"2026-11-10T16:06:46Z","pinned":false},"limits":{"coverage":{"history":"full","held_since":"2023-06-09","gaps":[],"covered":["ToFR L1"],"not_covered":["national guidance","court decisions"]},"freshness":{"release_id":"2d86bd12ba77a288053b34ea2517324b92d03c8039b7f5d156fa4002421384a1","release_published":"2026-11-10T16:06:46Z","checked_at":null,"checked_against":null},"truncation":{"shown":38,"total":38,"capped":false,"cap":1000,"next_cursor":null},"failures":[],"incomplete":[]},"page":{"path":"/tofr/articles/38","url":"https://www.headlesslaw.com/tofr/articles/38","title":"Article 38 — Amendments to Directive (EU) 2015/849","work_id":"tofr","date_state":"past","as_of":"2023-06-09","relations_url":"https://www.headlesslaw.com/tofr/articles/38/relations"},"as_of":"2023-06-09","counts":{"refers_to:out":27,"uses_term:out":11},"relations":[{"edge_id":"8d8f4ea07085ed2a5249","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3(1)","dst_raw":"eu.mica.article.3","other":{"work_id":"mica","level":null,"locator":null,"url":null,"title":null,"key":"eu.mica.article.3","state_on_date":null},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.5","target_act":"Regulation (EU) 2023/1114","target_celex":"32023R1114"}},{"edge_id":"e9f2c862ae3a1ede5453","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.article.3","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3","url":"/tofr/articles/3","title":"Definitions","key":"3","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.5"}},{"edge_id":"f53a03d2219db54e6896","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 24a","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.5","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"7a9eae6976747983905d","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 47(1)","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.8.paragraph.3","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"8fcf62ac63dc0ccea05f","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 2(1)","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.8.paragraph.3","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"b0305f9cdc061ca44cce","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 19a(1)","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.8.paragraph.3","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"c450fb739a987456db48","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 19b(1)","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.8.paragraph.3","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"cb71d3bf9447d7c51eb8","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.8.paragraph.3","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"fceab60b1f632b1d73fc","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 45(9)","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.8.paragraph.3","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"2ee6a9a81482d23f4fae","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 19b","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.4.subparagraph.3","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"025c2701fd2ed7089602","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 47","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.7","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"1a170612826a1f78530d","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 2(1)","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.1","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"83ac3952e583f410d870","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 18","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.3","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"5f7bc68b4697e3bd560e","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.2","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"430cf86bf93b56451256","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"unresolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 2(2)","dst_raw":"that Regulation","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.2.subpoint.c.subpoint.18","target_act":"that Regulation","target_celex":null}},{"edge_id":"d6c990bc1759d4ad6458","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3(1)","dst_raw":"eu.mica.article.3","other":{"work_id":"mica","level":null,"locator":null,"url":null,"title":null,"key":"eu.mica.article.3","state_on_date":null},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.2.subpoint.c.subpoint.18","target_act":"Regulation (EU) 2023/1114","target_celex":"32023R1114"}},{"edge_id":"5fea15b5ddb471e9a167","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3(1)","dst_raw":"eu.mica.article.3","other":{"work_id":"mica","level":null,"locator":null,"url":null,"title":null,"key":"eu.mica.article.3","state_on_date":null},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.4.subparagraph.3.paragraph.1","target_act":"Regulation (EU) 2023/1114","target_celex":"32023R1114"}},{"edge_id":"7997e07c231dad7529eb","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 13","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.article.13","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/13","url":"/tofr/articles/13","title":"Assessment and reporting","key":"13","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.4.subparagraph.3.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"eb84454df6783c991b89","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 19","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.4.subparagraph.3.paragraph.1","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"10ca43533991434dda9e","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 19a","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.4","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"0e027a3db1ede185dac1","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"unresolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3(1)","dst_raw":"that Regulation","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.2.subpoint.c.subpoint.19","target_act":"that Regulation","target_celex":null}},{"edge_id":"f12a2d11a7d13a73ac7d","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3(1)","dst_raw":"eu.mica.article.3","other":{"work_id":"mica","level":null,"locator":null,"url":null,"title":null,"key":"eu.mica.article.3","state_on_date":null},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.2.subpoint.c.subpoint.19","target_act":"Regulation (EU) 2023/1114","target_celex":"32023R1114"}},{"edge_id":"740ae2484c80d9fd1e40","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 3","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.article.3","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3","url":"/tofr/articles/3","title":"Definitions","key":"3","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.2.subpoint.d.subpoint.20"}},{"edge_id":"07e14a9bc6cc91db8677","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 67","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.8","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"1985536715ef045aaaed","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 45","dst_raw":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.6","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/849","target_celex":"32015L0849"}},{"edge_id":"2bb593dba8c068bca845","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 2","dst_raw":"eu.emd.article.2","other":{"work_id":"emd","level":null,"locator":null,"url":null,"title":null,"key":"eu.emd.article.2","state_on_date":null},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.6.paragraph.9","target_act":"Directive 2009/110/EC","target_celex":"32009L0110"}},{"edge_id":"3799327f7640c54d2467","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 4","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.4","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":null,"locator":null,"url":null,"title":null,"key":"eu.psd2.article.4","state_on_date":null},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1.point.6.paragraph.9","target_act":"Directive (EU) 2015/2366","target_celex":"32015L2366"}},{"edge_id":"01b4709f1978e97d8ca0","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"self-hosted address","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.self-hosted-address","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/20","url":"/definitions/tofr/self-hosted-address","title":"Definitions","key":"3(20)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"02c597d0b6eeb6fa09f7","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"crypto-assets","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.crypto-asset","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/14","url":"/definitions/tofr/crypto-asset","title":"Definitions","key":"3(14)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"249c73a0039a7e3851a2","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"crypto-asset service providers","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.crypto-asset-service-provider","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/15","url":"/definitions/tofr/crypto-asset-service-provider","title":"Definitions","key":"3(15)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"480d69c5c98b4e11c6a6","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"originator","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.originator","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/21","url":"/definitions/tofr/originator","title":"Definitions","key":"3(21)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"571b0a0dc29d52439253","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"beneficiary","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.beneficiary","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/22","url":"/definitions/tofr/beneficiary","title":"Definitions","key":"3(22)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"578133d4bdb8cec1d3c8","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"crypto-asset accounts","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.crypto-asset-account","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/19","url":"/definitions/tofr/crypto-asset-account","title":"Definitions","key":"3(19)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"617bbbf87064181b610d","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"funds","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.funds","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/8","url":"/definitions/tofr/funds","title":"Definitions","key":"3(8)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"76b70224f9876df566bb","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"terrorist financing","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.terrorist-financing","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/1","url":"/definitions/tofr/terrorist-financing","title":"Definitions","key":"3(1)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"85dbf947b1e0bed98532","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"money laundering","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.money-laundering","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/2","url":"/definitions/tofr/money-laundering","title":"Definitions","key":"3(2)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"c7975a5c511d47bd35a9","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"payment service providers","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.payment-service-provider","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/5","url":"/definitions/tofr/payment-service-provider","title":"Definitions","key":"3(5)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"f9a338ecc6d357c67dbc","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"transfers of crypto-assets","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.transfer-of-crypto-assets","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/10","url":"/definitions/tofr/transfer-of-crypto-assets","title":"Definitions","key":"3(10)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.38","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.38.subparagraph.1"}}],"not_served":["exempts","derogates_from"],"note":"inverse edges are computed from the stored direction; floating targets are resolved on as_of (other.state_on_date)"}