{"release":{"id":"2d86bd12ba77a288053b34ea2517324b92d03c8039b7f5d156fa4002421384a1","published":"2026-11-10T16:06:46Z","pinned":false},"limits":{"coverage":{"history":"full","held_since":"2023-06-09","gaps":[],"covered":["ToFR L1"],"not_covered":["national guidance","court decisions"]},"freshness":{"release_id":"2d86bd12ba77a288053b34ea2517324b92d03c8039b7f5d156fa4002421384a1","release_published":"2026-11-10T16:06:46Z","checked_at":null,"checked_against":null},"truncation":{"shown":14,"total":14,"capped":false,"cap":1000,"next_cursor":null},"failures":[],"incomplete":[]},"page":{"path":"/tofr/articles/12","url":"https://www.headlesslaw.com/tofr/articles/12","title":"Article 12 — Transfers of funds with missing information on the payer or the payee","work_id":"tofr","date_state":"current","as_of":"2026-11-11","relations_url":"https://www.headlesslaw.com/tofr/articles/12/relations"},"as_of":"2026-11-11","counts":{"uses_term:out":9,"refers_to:out":5},"relations":[{"edge_id":"01a839a6a19a4483d936","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"payee","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.payee","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/4","url":"/definitions/tofr/payee","title":"Definitions","key":"3(4)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1.point.b"}},{"edge_id":"561d119b7559346a6e44","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"payer","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.payer","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/3","url":"/definitions/tofr/payer","title":"Definitions","key":"3(3)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1.point.b"}},{"edge_id":"d8b41bc6570edc79a6bf","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"transfer of funds","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.transfer-of-funds","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/9","url":"/definitions/tofr/transfer-of-funds","title":"Definitions","key":"3(9)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1.point.b"}},{"edge_id":"0688c5522d51b347e36c","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"payment service provider","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.payment-service-provider","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/5","url":"/definitions/tofr/payment-service-provider","title":"Definitions","key":"3(5)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"0513ba78ec37ce6ff74e","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"payer","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.payer","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/3","url":"/definitions/tofr/payer","title":"Definitions","key":"3(3)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"3146f375fcf58be4fd51","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 4(2)","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.article.4","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/4","url":"/tofr/articles/4","title":"Information accompanying transfers of funds","key":"4","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"3516be0d09e731de79e7","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"intermediary payment service provider","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.intermediary-payment-service-provider","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/6","url":"/definitions/tofr/intermediary-payment-service-provider","title":"Definitions","key":"3(6)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"40b0057414bd06a97df6","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"payee","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.payee","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/4","url":"/definitions/tofr/payee","title":"Definitions","key":"3(4)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"5ab9994add5141bfff6d","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"transfer of funds","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.transfer-of-funds","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/9","url":"/definitions/tofr/transfer-of-funds","title":"Definitions","key":"3(9)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"80efdb6bb6f8616fa82f","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 5(1)","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.article.5","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/5","url":"/tofr/articles/5","title":"Transfers of funds within the Union","key":"5","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"85bf06813b96b86ad7b0","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 6","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.article.6","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/6","url":"/tofr/articles/6","title":"Transfers of funds to outside the Union","key":"6","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"b690a5a7446fbfcdc054","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 4(1)","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.article.4","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/4","url":"/tofr/articles/4","title":"Information accompanying transfers of funds","key":"4","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"f24b3d4befe29ee96095","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"Article 7(1)","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.article.7","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/7","url":"/tofr/articles/7","title":"Detection of missing information on the payer or the payee","key":"7","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"953f9ecdf986aa01831f","scope":"unit","type":"uses_term","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_link_pass","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"high","src_from":"2023-06-09","src_until":null,"span":"funds","dst_raw":"eu.tofr.definition.funds","other":{"work_id":"tofr","level":"L1","locator":"tofr/art/3/para/8","url":"/definitions/tofr/funds","title":"Definitions","key":"3(8)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.tofr.legal_text.article.12","source_block_id":"eu.tofr.article.12.paragraph.2.point.b"}}],"not_served":["exempts","derogates_from"],"note":"inverse edges are computed from the stored direction; floating targets are resolved on as_of (other.state_on_date)"}