{"release":{"id":"2d86bd12ba77a288053b34ea2517324b92d03c8039b7f5d156fa4002421384a1","published":"2026-11-10T16:06:46Z","pinned":false},"limits":{"coverage":{"history":"full","held_since":"2015-12-23","gaps":[],"covered":["PSD2 L1"],"not_covered":["national guidance","court decisions"]},"freshness":{"release_id":"2d86bd12ba77a288053b34ea2517324b92d03c8039b7f5d156fa4002421384a1","release_published":"2026-11-10T16:06:46Z","checked_at":null,"checked_against":null},"truncation":{"shown":17,"total":17,"capped":false,"cap":1000,"next_cursor":null},"failures":[],"incomplete":[]},"page":{"path":"/psd2/articles/89","url":"https://www.headlesslaw.com/psd2/articles/89","title":"Article 89 — Payment service providers’ liability for non-execution, defective or late execution of payment transactions","work_id":"psd2","date_state":"past","as_of":"2025-01-17","relations_url":"https://www.headlesslaw.com/psd2/articles/89/relations"},"as_of":"2025-01-17","counts":{"refers_to:out":10,"corrected_by:out":3,"amended_by:out":1,"refers_to:in":3},"relations":[{"edge_id":"1ca23a48b3979c9e5192","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 83(1)","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.83","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/83","url":"/psd2/articles/83","title":"Payment transactions to a payment account","key":"83","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"40b72e9ca46802187318","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 88(2)","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.88","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/88","url":"/psd2/articles/88","title":"Incorrect unique identifiers","key":"88","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"41fa2284ce1940ffa034","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 87","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.87","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/87","url":"/psd2/articles/87","title":"Value date and availability of funds","key":"87","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"56faacf3fdb9743b64cb","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 71","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.71","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/71","url":"/psd2/articles/71","title":"Notification and rectification of unauthorised or incorrectly executed payment transactions","key":"71","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"57bb97de8d04e6fb3a64","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 93","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.93","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/93","url":"/psd2/articles/93","title":"Abnormal and unforeseeable circumstances","key":"93","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"1075c00242ceee591240","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 87","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.87","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/87","url":"/psd2/articles/87","title":"Value date and availability of funds","key":"87","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"30c0c21b171a8366e973","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 88(2)","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.88","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/88","url":"/psd2/articles/88","title":"Incorrect unique identifiers","key":"88","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"60872daa4383f432ab76","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 93","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.93","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/93","url":"/psd2/articles/93","title":"Abnormal and unforeseeable circumstances","key":"93","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"8c5f4fee7b7888d46a19","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 83(3)","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.83","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/83","url":"/psd2/articles/83","title":"Payment transactions to a payment account","key":"83","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"964916e72c37906ac30f","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 71","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.71","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/71","url":"/psd2/articles/71","title":"Notification and rectification of unauthorised or incorrectly executed payment transactions","key":"71","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.89.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"351c9d11df97e92a555e","scope":"unit","type":"corrected_by","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"cellar_corrigendum","method":"eurlex_corrigendum","confidence":"exact","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 89(2), fourth subparagraph, first sentence","dst_raw":"32015L2366R(05)","other":null,"evidence":{"corrigendum_published":"2018-04-23","corrigendum_url":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2015/2366/corrigendum/2018-04-23/oj"}},{"edge_id":"826a3264b75a2417f638","scope":"unit","type":"corrected_by","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"cellar_corrigendum","method":"eurlex_corrigendum","confidence":"exact","src_from":"2015-12-23","src_until":null,"span":"Article 89(2), fourth subparagraph, first sentence","dst_raw":"32015L2366R(05)","other":null,"evidence":{"corrigendum_published":"2018-04-23","corrigendum_url":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2015/2366/corrigendum/2018-04-23/oj"}},{"edge_id":"c6a9c12acaa4ad2abe48","scope":"unit","type":"corrected_by","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"cellar_corrigendum","method":"eurlex_corrigendum","confidence":"exact","src_from":"2024-04-08","src_until":null,"span":"Article 89(2), fourth subparagraph, first sentence","dst_raw":"32015L2366R(05)","other":null,"evidence":{"corrigendum_published":"2018-04-23","corrigendum_url":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2015/2366/corrigendum/2018-04-23/oj"}},{"edge_id":"dd4457b3e479d06d60b8","scope":"unit","type":"amended_by","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"cellar_consolidation_metadata","method":"cellar-inventory","confidence":"single_act","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":null,"dst_raw":"32022L2556","other":null,"evidence":{"consolidation":"02015L2366-20250117","incorporates":["32022L2556"]}},{"edge_id":"5746a79afa2cc34fa757","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 89","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.89","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/88/para/2","url":"/psd2/articles/88#p-2","title":"Incorrect unique identifiers","key":"88(2)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.88","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.88.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"e1ca38161a0cf922f2fc","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 89","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.89","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/71/para/1","url":"/psd2/articles/71#p-1","title":"Notification and rectification of unauthorised or incorrectly executed payment transactions","key":"71(1)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.71","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.71.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"e377401c48c8e4bad260","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 89(1)","dst_raw":"eu.psd2.article.89","other":{"work_id":"psd2","level":"L1","locator":"psd2/art/71/para/2","url":"/psd2/articles/71#p-2","title":"Notification and rectification of unauthorised or incorrectly executed payment transactions","key":"71(2)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.psd2.legal_text.article.71","source_block_id":"eu.psd2.article.71.paragraph.2"}}],"not_served":["exempts","derogates_from"],"note":"inverse edges are computed from the stored direction; floating targets are resolved on as_of (other.state_on_date)"}