{"release":{"id":"2d86bd12ba77a288053b34ea2517324b92d03c8039b7f5d156fa4002421384a1","published":"2026-11-10T16:06:46Z","pinned":false},"limits":{"coverage":{"history":"full","held_since":"2012-07-27","gaps":[],"covered":["EMIR L1"],"not_covered":["national guidance","court decisions"]},"freshness":{"release_id":"2d86bd12ba77a288053b34ea2517324b92d03c8039b7f5d156fa4002421384a1","release_published":"2026-11-10T16:06:46Z","checked_at":null,"checked_against":null},"truncation":{"shown":35,"total":35,"capped":false,"cap":1000,"next_cursor":null},"failures":[],"incomplete":[]},"page":{"path":"/emir/articles/14","url":"https://www.headlesslaw.com/emir/articles/14","title":"Article 14 — Authorisation of a CCP","work_id":"emir","date_state":"current","as_of":"2026-11-11","relations_url":"https://www.headlesslaw.com/emir/articles/14/relations"},"as_of":"2026-11-11","counts":{"amended_by:out":2,"refers_to:out":3,"refers_to:in":28,"answers:in":2},"relations":[{"edge_id":"97a21a4275799ba8d2be","scope":"unit","type":"amended_by","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"cellar_consolidation_metadata","method":"cellar-inventory","confidence":"single_act","src_from":"2024-12-24","src_until":null,"span":null,"dst_raw":"32024R2987","other":null,"evidence":{"consolidation":"02012R0648-20241224","incorporates":["32024R2987"]}},{"edge_id":"f913b413489e14c9807b","scope":"unit","type":"amended_by","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"cellar_consolidation_metadata","method":"cellar-inventory","confidence":"single_act","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":null,"dst_raw":"32022R2554","other":{"work_id":"spaces/dora/level-3/opinions/jc-2025-06-opinion-rts-subcontracting","level":null,"locator":null,"url":null,"title":null,"key":"32022R2554","state_on_date":null},"evidence":{"consolidation":"02012R0648-20250117","incorporates":["32022R2554"]}},{"edge_id":"6d0d0ab0640707d4d7e7","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 17","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.17","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/17","url":"/emir/articles/17","title":"Procedure for granting and refusing authorisation","key":"17","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.14","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.14.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"0da6794f1c805bfb8003","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 17","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.17","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/17","url":"/emir/articles/17","title":"Procedure for granting and refusing authorisation","key":"17","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.14","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.14.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"2cf73193c641487caa31","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"out","resolution":"external","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 15","dst_raw":"Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010","other":null,"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.14","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.14.paragraph.7","target_act":"Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010","target_celex":"32010R1095"}},{"edge_id":"08b0a27f0d50b031afec","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/24/para/7","url":"/emir/articles/24#p-7","title":"Emergency situations","key":"24(7)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.24","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.24.paragraph.7"}},{"edge_id":"0c1493de69dd8b693042","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/24/para/1/pt/a","url":"/emir/articles/24#p-1-a","title":"Emergency situations","key":"24(1)(a)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.24","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.24.paragraph.1.point.a"}},{"edge_id":"146fc06bbdb3638d6722","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/25/para/2c/subpara/6/pt/a","url":"/emir/articles/25#p-2c-a","title":"Recognition of a third-country CCP","key":"25(2c)(a)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.25","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.25.paragraph.2c.subparagraph.6.point.a"}},{"edge_id":"18bc063c927f45b117cc","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/7a/para/1","url":"/emir/articles/7a#p-1","title":"Active account","key":"7a(1)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.7a","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.7a.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"1e17ef8d31a3e8e44964","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/7a/para/5","url":"/emir/articles/7a#p-5","title":"Active account","key":"7a(5)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.7a","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.7a.paragraph.5"}},{"edge_id":"2027a49477c1cd714fd2","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/4a/para/5","url":"/emir/articles/4a#p-5","title":"Financial counterparties that are subject to the clearing obligation","key":"4a(5)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.4a","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.4a.paragraph.5"}},{"edge_id":"20be2d6caba94e5f02c4","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/5/para/1","url":"/emir/articles/5#p-1","title":"Clearing obligation procedure","key":"5(1)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.5","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.5.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"287b2014b3c963b3aa5d","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14(6)","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/17/para/2","url":"/emir/articles/17#p-2","title":"Procedure for granting and refusing authorisation","key":"17(2)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.17","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.17.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"29d3a4daf0879fb6a2e2","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/89/para/12","url":"/emir/articles/89#p-12","title":"Transitional provisions","key":"89(12)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.89.paragraph.12"}},{"edge_id":"2a65a258aa701fc80d11","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/24a/para/7/pt/ba","url":"/emir/articles/24a#p-7-ba","title":"CCP Supervisory Committee","key":"24a(7)(ba)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.24a","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.24a.paragraph.7.point.ba"}},{"edge_id":"3a4be8d55856c13e58b7","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/17c/para/2","url":"/emir/articles/17c#p-2","title":"Central database","key":"17c(2)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.17c","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.17c.paragraph.2"}},{"edge_id":"3b05a8121b14e10acc71","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/40/subpara/1","url":"/emir/articles/40","title":"Exposure management","key":"40","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.40","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.40.subparagraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"51b3ecb7760352169ad4","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/23b/para/2/pt/a/subpt/iii","url":"/emir/articles/23b#p-2-a-iii","title":"Joint Monitoring Mechanism","key":"23b(2)(a)(iii)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.23b","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.23b.paragraph.2.point.a.subpoint.iii"}},{"edge_id":"580567d8d9bfc618caf3","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14(1)","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/17/para/2/pt/a","url":"/emir/articles/17#p-2-a","title":"Procedure for granting and refusing authorisation","key":"17(2)(a)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.17","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.17.paragraph.2.point.a"}},{"edge_id":"5abd8d1c65e95e8c7ae2","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/7e/para/1","url":"/emir/articles/7e#p-1","title":"Information on Union CCPs","key":"7e(1)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.7e","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.7e.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"5f747099c8e561708dcd","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/24a/para/2/pt/d/subpt/ii","url":"/emir/articles/24a#p-2-d-ii","title":"CCP Supervisory Committee","key":"24a(2)(d)(ii)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.24a","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.24a.paragraph.2.point.d.subpoint.ii"}},{"edge_id":"636b8d86b255c37f07ba","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/4/para/3","url":"/emir/articles/4#p-3","title":"Clearing obligation","key":"4(3)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.4","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.4.paragraph.3"}},{"edge_id":"645d6e53e29fb17413bf","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/89/para/3","url":"/emir/articles/89#p-3","title":"Transitional provisions","key":"89(3)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.89","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.89.paragraph.3"}},{"edge_id":"77ac25dcfbc67a114afa","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/7c/para/1","url":"/emir/articles/7c#p-1","title":"Information on the provision of clearing services","key":"7c(1)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.7c","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.7c.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"8dfdc2be197bf210119c","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/17/para/4","url":"/emir/articles/17#p-4","title":"Procedure for granting and refusing authorisation","key":"17(4)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.17","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.17.paragraph.4"}},{"edge_id":"8e65c3cb9ec0efda5586","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/24a/para/7","url":"/emir/articles/24a#p-7","title":"CCP Supervisory Committee","key":"24a(7)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.24a","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.24a.paragraph.7"}},{"edge_id":"952776b34adb7e5309d3","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14(1)","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/17/para/1","url":"/emir/articles/17#p-1","title":"Procedure for granting and refusing authorisation","key":"17(1)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.17","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.17.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"a15ba372981dee9e27cf","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/24a/para/7/pt/c/subpt/iv","url":"/emir/articles/24a#p-7-c-iv","title":"CCP Supervisory Committee","key":"24a(7)(c)(iv)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.24a","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.24a.paragraph.7.point.c.subpoint.iv"}},{"edge_id":"aae97d5540a83ec781d4","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/23b/para/2/pt/a/subpt/ii","url":"/emir/articles/23b#p-2-a-ii","title":"Joint Monitoring Mechanism","key":"23b(2)(a)(ii)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.23b","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.23b.paragraph.2.point.a.subpoint.ii"}},{"edge_id":"d5510e5aa972b122344f","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/24/para/8","url":"/emir/articles/24#p-8","title":"Emergency situations","key":"24(8)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.24","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.24.paragraph.8"}},{"edge_id":"dcc6bc072d65901f6bd8","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/16/para/1","url":"/emir/articles/16#p-1","title":"Capital requirements","key":"16(1)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.16","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.16.paragraph.1"}},{"edge_id":"e2f6805a1dbb5de75b9c","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14(1)","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/17/para/3/pt/a","url":"/emir/articles/17#p-3-a","title":"Procedure for granting and refusing authorisation","key":"17(3)(a)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.17","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.17.paragraph.3.point.a"}},{"edge_id":"f836ee0d7a3f304fe2de","scope":"unit","type":"refers_to","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"explicit_legal_cross_reference","method":"extracted_relationships","confidence":"medium","src_from":"2025-01-17","src_until":null,"span":"Article 14","dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"emir","level":"L1","locator":"emir/art/6/para/2/pt/g","url":"/emir/articles/6#p-2-g","title":"Public register","key":"6(2)(g)","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"object":"eu.emir.legal_text.article.6","source_block_id":"eu.emir.article.6.paragraph.2.point.g"}},{"edge_id":"b58c725083803be435e9","scope":"unit","type":"answers","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_mapping","method":"stated_legal_basis","confidence":"curated","src_from":"2015-03-31","src_until":null,"span":null,"dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"spaces/emir/level-3/q-and-a/esma/esma-qa-861-authorisation-of-a-ccp","level":"L3","locator":"spaces/emir/level-3/q-and-a/esma/esma-qa-861-authorisation-of-a-ccp/page","url":"/emir/level-3/q-and-a/esma/esma-qa-861-authorisation-of-a-ccp","title":"Q&A — Authorisation of a CCP [Answer Published]","key":"ESMA Q&A 861","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"evidence":"legal_basis: Article 14 of EMIR - old CCP question 6 dated 31/03/2015","doc_type":"qa"}},{"edge_id":"c44e07cd30d41d99bfcc","scope":"unit","type":"answers","direction":"in","resolution":"resolved","basis":"curated_mapping","method":"stated_legal_basis","confidence":"curated","src_from":"2013-06-04","src_until":null,"span":null,"dst_raw":"eu.emir.article.14","other":{"work_id":"spaces/emir/level-3/q-and-a/esma/esma-qa-865-outsourcing-old-ccp-question-10-dated-4-06-2013","level":"L3","locator":"spaces/emir/level-3/q-and-a/esma/esma-qa-865-outsourcing-old-ccp-question-10-dated-4-06-2013/page","url":"/emir/level-3/q-and-a/esma/esma-qa-865-outsourcing-old-ccp-question-10-dated-4-06-2013","title":"Q&A — Outsourcing (old CCP question 10 dated 4/06/2013) [Answer Published]","key":"ESMA Q&A 865","state_on_date":"in_force"},"evidence":{"evidence":"legal_basis: Article 14 of EMIR - old CCP question 10 dated 4/06/2013","doc_type":"qa"}}],"not_served":["exempts","derogates_from"],"note":"inverse edges are computed from the stored direction; floating targets are resolved on as_of (other.state_on_date)"}